Privacy-friendly social networks

This semester privacy came up several times during classes. As I wrote my previous thesis and am writing my current thesis on privacy issues and beliefs, I love to hear people’s opinion about it. It seems like our group is fairly privacy minded, or in any case aware of the potential threats and dangers.

One such threat is profiling. Every site you visit or post you like tells marketers and advertisers something about who you are. Your data is super interesting for them because it enables them to tailor their ads or to discover interesting ideas and trends. They are willing to pay a lot for this data. We became the product. That’s also the business model of Facebook.

It’s the dissatisfaction with this way of making money that is the driving force behind Ello, Minds, Vivaldi and Tsu; four alternative social networking sites. Ello, Minds and Vivaldi don’t sell and read user information or show advertisements. How is it possible for a free service to make money then? Ello offers his users the possibility to personalise their Ello-experience for payment.

Tsu tries another tack. They also challenge the adage that we are the product, but in another way: if our data is being sold, then WE should get paid for it. The more interesting content you produce, the more money you make.

The main problem is that Facebook is still the most popular social network. If your friends and family aren’t motivated to leave Facebook, it is not interesting for you too. Maybe when privacy concerns grow, people will be more encouraged to seek alternatives like Ello and Tsu.

Privacy-friendly social networks

Virtual reality

Two weeks ago the Short Film Festival took place in Leuven. Besides a lot of short films, they also organised a couple activities. One was a seminar about virtual reality and the possibility to try out several VR glasses and projects. Unfortunately, I didn’t make it to STUK, but I googled the speakers and surfed the web to find out more.

One of the speakers was Joan Llobera. On Limo I found an interesting article of her: “Telling Stories within Immersive Virtual Environments”. Llobera and the other authors propose two methods to combine user interaction and a strong narrative, because it’s difficult to unfold a story in an interactive environment because the player has a lot of freedom. A second guest speaker was Avinash Changa, CEO and founder of WeMakeVR. One example of what can be done with VR is experiencing the Tommy Hilfiger runway show like a VIP on the front row and peek behind the scenes.

It seems like VR is the next big thing. Samsung, Sony, HTC, Nokia are all busy developing virtual reality platforms and headsets. Google developed cardboard virtual reality glasses which makes it possible to get to know VR in an affordable way. You just fold it and then you watch 360° videos on YouTube on your mobile phone or download an app from your favourite store.

Content producers also take the leap. 20th Century Fox collaborates with Oculus: they will make several blockbusters available for the Oculus Rift and the Samsung Gear VR. Also Lions Gate Entertainment will make movies available for VR-glasses. It looks like in the near future we will be able to watch movies like the The Hunger Games, Die Hard, Alien and Taken in 3D from our living room through our VR-glasses.

But we can go one step further than “just” watching 3D pictures or movies. It becomes really cool when you are immersed in a virtual world. You can say you are immersed in a virtual world when that world reacts to your movements. You see a different perspective when you turn your head or when you walk around. Also in this are we see much new technologies emerging. Like this one.

If you are still looking for a cool Christmas gift, I think VR glasses or a Google Cardboard are a great idea!

 

 

 

 

Virtual reality

Future prospects

This week we’ve talked about our future prospects and job opportunities. It was a good nudge for me to think a little bit more specific about what I want to do after graduating. I would love to combine my degree in Communication Sciences with the skills I’m acquiring this year. For example analysing the data of a media outlet or keeping track of new developments and technologies to use as a new way for telling stories.

After completing all the selected courses, I will at least have a basic notion of data managing, data mining, data visualisation, programming with Python and project management. I do think all of this is relevant and I was fairly optimistic over my future prospects, although I got a little bit disillusioned by last lecture and the many unanswered job applications of professor Bordalejo. After all she did found her current job and as I’m not pursuing an academic career, I’m still quite optimistic.

After class I read a news article that supported my positive vision. IBM surveyed 5200 managers from around the world about the digital future and the new competitors it will bring. Especially the BENELUX-countries are aware of the crucial influence of technology and of cyber threats and are planning partnerships. “But although the Belgians realize the world is changing, the don’t necessarily adapt themselves well.” The world is digitizing, but although the BENELUX companies are aware, they aren’t currently adapting.

We as digital humanities-students are in a great position. We know a lot about digitisation and new developments and technologies. So maybe we can advise businesses how they should adapt to all this new technologies. Take for example a broadcasting company. We can investigate who will become their digital competitors (Youtube and Netflix), what are there strengths in comparison to their new competitors, do they have interesting data and what can we deduce therefrom (for example: who is in the most successful TV shows?), what are pitfalls in the digital future (be careful of the privacy of your customers/users!), and what are opportunities (virtual reality glasses, AXES,…)

It looks like maybe I can become a digital SWOT-analyst…

Future prospects

Another side of games

Two weeks ago, we were talking about games and their educational potential. The term “gamification” was mentioned again and that reminded me of a lecture of last year of professor Aupers (yes, the one I’ve mentioned in my first post 😉 ). He showed us the following video.

In the video a smartmeter and an accompanying game are described. The smartmeter allows you to see how much energy you’re consuming at any time. The accompanying game shows you your virtual house, how you are consuming energy and how you can lower it. For example: “Microwaves use 50% less energy than ovens.” Furthermore it shows how much energy you, your neighbours and other people are using. “The only way to improve your virtual home, is to lower the energy uses in your real one!”

I believe it’s a nice example of the educational and motivating potential of games. It seems fun to “play” the game. It would definitely make me more aware of how much energy I’m consuming and I also believe the social element can be a strong motivation. Of course, you could raise privacy-issues, related not only to the exposure of your energy level but also to smart meters and the Internet of Things, but I will not elaborate more on that in this post.

The example is a clear illustration of the definition of gamification I read on Dennis’s blog: the use of game design and game mechanics in non-game contexts.

When I was consulting my notes of last year, I found another interesting example in the context of gamification, although I’m not sure if it fits Dennis’ definition as nicely as the first example. In 2005 the World of Warcraft was swept by a virtual epidemic: the Corrupted Blood Plague.

Players were supposed to fight against Hakkar, who attacked the players with the Corrupted Blood spell. Because some players got cursed but didn’t die or defeated Hakkar, the Corrupted Blood virus could spread. Apparently, it was really interesting for epidemiologists and (bio-)terrorism scholars to study the way “people” behaved and the impact of the virtual virus. They could watch how “people” interacted and behaved without having the disastrous consequences.

The second example doesn’t seem to satisfy the definition completely: we’re not taking game elements and putting them in another context. It’s more the other way around. We’re studying human behaviour in a game context.

Anyway, I like these two examples because they illustrate another side of games, besides the entertaining one.

Another side of games

Authenticity

In this week’s course, we talked about social media and the Digital Humanities. Therefor we read Manovich’s paper “Trending: the promises and the challenges of big social data”. He argued that “the emergence of social media in the middle of the 2000’s created opportunities to study social and cultural processes and dynamics in new ways”. The huge amount of social media data bridges the gap between surface data and deep data. With surface data Manovich aims at the data about lots of people, gathered with surveys in most cases and statistically analyzed. Deep data on the other hand, are data about few people, gathered through observation or extensive interviewing for example. But Manovich also made four objections to this very optimistic idea about the opportunities of social media data.

One of his objections (and one that was also mentioned during class) was that we cannot consider social media data as authentic. “These are not a transparant window into people’s imaginations, intentions, motifs, opinions, and ideas. It’s more appropriate to think of it as an interface people present to the world.” Our online life and behavior doesn’t mirror our offline behavior. It’s like the online version of ourself is a more idealized one.

That’s also what a team of researchers found. Bessière, Seay and Kiesler surveyed 51 players of World of Warcraft via e-mail. They saw that the respondent’s avatar resembled more their ideal self than their actual self (the avatar was more extravert, less neurotic and more conscientious). This was even more true for people who felt more depressed or had a lower self-esteem. For those people the discrepancy between their actual self and their avatar was bigger. Our real life personality thus influences our online presentation. If we feel happy, we don’t feed the need to fake. So, on- and offline behaviors are clearly related.

But the question remains how authentic are online presentations are. You could say they are absolutely not authentic. It doesn’t resemble our offline self. You couldn’t say that all our Facebook and Instagram pictures mirror reality, especially not after the recent confession of blogster Essena O’Neill who admitted she was frequently posing for two hours to get the perfect picture.

But I was thinking that maybe our posts and pictures do reflect our aspirations and imaginations. They resemble who we WANT to be. In that sense, our online behavior is authentic. Maybe even more authentic…  Also the anonymity the world wide web offers, makes it possible to be often more honest than you would be in real life. I sometimes google something, instead of asking someone, because it’s an embarrasing question.

The point is that we can derive lots of insights from social media data, but we have to be cautious. Not only do we have to question the authenticity, but we also need to be aware of the people behind the data when we generalize our findings. Don’t say for example: “the Belgian population is frightened” based on Twitter-data only. The typical Twitter users are young and well-educated, but that’s only a subset of Belgium.

Humans stay crucial to interpret and use the data!

Authenticity

Normal?

What we perceive als normal or natural is socially constructed.

  • This girl can be considered as a natural beauty.

hmprod

  • And this is how legs of a natural beauty should look like.

smooth legs

  • It’s normal to read and write from left to right.

Schermafbeelding 2015-11-14 om 13.49.58

  • It’s normal to use a keyboard when using a computer.

Dell_Inspiron_laptop_keyboard_2014-02-07-2

But it all could be different!

  • Around 1800 Rubenesque women were considered most beautiful.

Rubens05

  • Why do women shave their legs actually?

hairy legs

  • Among others, Arabic, Hebrew and Syriac are read and written from right to left.

Schermafbeelding 2015-11-14 om 13.50.34

  • Maybe in the future we control our computer with our mind.

Schermafbeelding 2015-11-14 om 18.20.28

Sources images:

http://www2.hm.com/

http://www.rp-press.com/bilder/gillette/v-o-model-2

http://xahlee.info/kbd/laptop_keyboards.html

http://www.wikipedia.com

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-3110599/Hairy-woman-stopped-shaving-legs-11-hits-ITV-s-Morning-claiming-cancelled-appearance-WASN-T-freak.html

http://www.bbci.de/

Normal?

Need for questions?

Tom Scheinfeldt asked two interesting questions. First of all he wondered if Digital Humanities have to answer questions? I don’t think DH have to answer questions in an imperative sense, but I do think DH answers questions. Even an explorative study asks a question and tries to formulate an answer. Take for example the visualization of the covers of Time Magazine. I suppose the researchers/artists didn’t have an idea already about what they would find. They were not able to set hypotheses yet. But they probably wondered if something interested could be derived from plotting the covers, and apparently it did! It’s very inspiring to see what other people are wondering and take a look at their results and interpretations.

Secondly, Tom Scheinfeldt asked what questions DH answers that can’t be answered without it. Indeed, why do we distinguish DH from the Humanities if they answer the same questions? In my opinion, Digital Humanists can answer the same questions as humanists. However, they have a different point of view, a different methodology, a different way to answer the same problem. For me, DH puts focus on technology, but it remains a part of the Humanities.

Nowadays, considering the omnipresence of technology, academics need to pay attention to technology and its influence on society. Marshall McLuhan already did in 1964 when he stated: “The medium is the message.” Technology has an influence on how a message is perceived. The best example to illustrate Marshall McLuhan’s statement is the debate between Nixon and Kennedy, which was broadcasted via the radio as well as on television. The radio listeners thought Nixon has won the debate, while the TV-viewers thought Kennedy was more convincing. This can easily be explained: Kennedy wore the right costume to appear on television, he looked good, confident and healthy. As opposed to Nixon, who was ill and looked pale. For me this is a brilliant illustration of the power of television. This makes clear the influence of technology on society.

It’s a classical example in Communication Sciences. Communication and media scientists pay a lot attention to technology (tv, smartphones, internet,…) and how it influences society and our worldview. So what’s the difference between Communication Sciences (who are paying attention to technology) and DH (who are supposed to focus on technology, as I stated before) I wondered while writing this blog post. I found an answer in Rockwell’s and Mactavish’s paper. Communication sciences are more a “thinking-about” academic field, while DH, who are using and developing tools and techniques, can be seen more as a “thinking-with” technology discipline.

Need for questions?

The Canterbury Tales

Last class professor Bordalejo introduced us to text encoding, defined by the TEI (the Text Encoding Initiative) as “making explicit an interpretation of a text”.

For example:

<title> Welcome to my blog </title>

Currently she and her team are encoding the Canterbury Tales so we can access them via the computer.

When I was 14 we went on a school journey to Kent. One thing we visited, apart from the Cathedral, was “The Canterbury Tales”. It was a sort of museum where the tales were told while you stood in the specific setting of it, which they had recreated.

To prepare ourselves for the trip, we should have had access to the digitized version of professor Bordalejo. One of our teachers would definitely love it! We studied the medieval Dutch poem “Karel ende Elegast”. We analysed each word, each letter, even all the notes in the margin.

When I told my sisters about (blogging about) the project of digitizing the Canterbury Tales, my youngest sister wondered: “What’s the point of digitizing old texts?” Well, I think the biggest advantage of all the digitized texts is their availability. That’s in line with some key features of DH: openness, accessibility, democratization of knowledge (Lisa Spiro). You don’t have to go to a library and were gloves to read it (at least, that’s how I imagine it would go). Now instead, you can read the Canterbury Tales or Dante’s work from behind your computer.

The Canterbury Tales